Action against Government servants who get appointment on the basis of false SC/ST/OBC certificates: DoPT Order
No.36011/1/2012-Estt. (Res.) Government of India Department of Personnel and Training Establishment (Reservation) Section North Block, New Delhi-110001 Dated the 10th January, 2013. OFFICE MEMORANDUM Sub:- Action against Government servants who get appointment on the basis of false SC/ST/OBC certificates. The undersigned is directed to invite reference to this Department's OM No
Verification of Castes Status by State Governments
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in its decision dated 2-9-1994 in the Case of Kumari Madhuri Patil versus Additional Commissioner, Tribal Development, Government of Maharashtra (Civil Appeal No. 5854 of 1994, arising out of SLP (Civil) No. 14767 of 1993) has directed that the caste certificates be scrutinised at the earliest and with utmost expedition and promptitude. The instructions of the Hon’
Action by CBI for getting job against fake caste certificates
During the last three years i.e. 2009, 2010, 2011 and 2012 (upto 31.10.2012), CBI has registered 50 cases against 51 persons on the allegations of getting jobs on the basis of fake caste certificates. The year-wise details of these cases are enclosed at Annexure-A. ANNEXURE-A STATEMENT REFERRED TO IN REPLY TO RAJYA SABHA UNSTARRED QUESTION NO. 3048 FOR 20.12.2012 REGARDING ACTION BY CBI
OBCs in Government jobs in comparison of SC/ST
(a): As per information received from various Ministries/ Departments, the Group- wise representation of Other Backward Classes (OBCs) in Central Government services as on 1.1.2011 is as under:- Groups Number of OBCs Percentage of OBCs A 5357 6.9 B 13,897 7.3 C 3,46,433 15.3 (erstwhile) D 81,468 17.0 (b) to (d)
Reservation for Persons with Disabilities: DoPT Order for compliance of Reservation Policy
DoPT has issued OM No.36035/6/2012-Estt.(Res.) dated 14-12-2012 regarding Reservation for Person with Disabilities. In this OM DoPT has instructed (i) for compliance of instructions related to carry forward of the unfilled reserved vacancies, interchange among the three categories of disability and lapsing of unfilled reserved vacancies and (ii) Preparation of reservation roster registers
Reservation in Promotion: Rajya Sabha Passes Constitutional Amendment Bill
Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances & Pensions17-December, 2012 Rajya Sabha Passes Constitutional Amendment Bill The Government of India has always been concerned about the welfare of downtrodden especially Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes. As a part of the affirmative action, reservation in promotion had been available to the SCs and STs since 1955. However, some decisions of
Group-wise Staff Strength and reservation in Ministries/Departments in Central Government
(a): The Group-wise estimated number of sanctioned posts in the Ministries/Departments in the Central Government as on 1.3.2011 is given in the table below:- Group A Group B Group C Total Number of sanctioned posts 98977 228755 3335797 3663529 Erstwhile Group D posts have been categorised as Group C after implementation of 6th Central Pay Commission. (b) & (c): The data about
Increase in Reservation Quota
(a) As per Census, 2001, the proportion of Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes in the country`s population is 16.2% and 8.2% respectively. (b) to (e) As per the information provided by the Department of Personnel and Training, the Hon`ble Supreme Court in the matter of Indra Sawhney Vs. Union of India observed that it is not possible to accept the theory of proportionate representation,
Representation of SC/ST in Group ‘C’ and ‘D’
Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances & Pensions12-December, 2012 Representation of SC/ST in Group ‘C’ and ‘D’ The representation of SC/ST has not declined in the previous years. The representation of SC and ST in posts and services of the Central Government as on 1.1.2009 in Group C was 16.4% and 7.2%, respectively, whereas as on 1.1.2011, the representation of SC and ST in Group C is
Reservation in Promotion Latest PIB Release
Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances & Pensions 12-December, 2012 Reservation in Promotion Reservation is available to Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes at the rate of 15% and 7.5%, respectively, in all Groups viz. A, B, C (including erstwhile Group D posts) in case of promotion by non-selection method. In case of promotion by selection method, reservation is available in Group B,
201 comments :
1 – 200 of 201 Newer› Newest»One year has already passes since closure of this scheme. CGEWHO is waiting for enhanced FAR.
I don't know how long they will wait to get enhanced FAR from GNIDA. It should be finalized soon for the welfare of applicants of this scheme.
Please provide the interest of the money already deposited by the applicant for this scheme.You are under no circumstance hold the money of applicant without interest more than six month as Govt. norms.Else you may process the application and declare the result soon.
Pl provide the interest of the money deposited by the applicant.Pl declare the result very soon.
When are you planning to do the lottery? Is this 10year plan or so... These are not the under the table or corrupt money. This is lifelong savings. Do something to take decision soon.....
It should be finalized soon for the welfare of applicants of this scheme.
please decide soon over it. applicants are waiting eagerly. either declare allottment or refund the deposited money with interst. it is hard-earned money.
15 months has already passes since closure the scheme. CGEWHO is waiting enhanced the FAR. I did't know how long they will wait to get enhanced FAR from GNIDA. You are under no circumstance hold the money of applicant without interest more then six months as Govt. norms. This is lifelong savings. Please do something to take decision soon and also declare the cost of all category flats.
I hope a decision is taken soon. CGEWHO can surely declare the waiting list so that the applicants who are low in the list can exit and plan to have a house elsewhere.The decision to Not pay interest is also very harsh- after all it is hard earned money. Mukesh
There is a provision to refund applicant money with interest whether it declared in advertisement. One should check advertisement of said project, however CGEWHO should take necessary action to publish waiting list early
god save govt employee from cgewho
So many Persons when applied were in service and after elapse of about 15 months might have retired . Why no prompt action is being taken by the CGEWHO authorities ? This is a big lapse on the part of the authorities. I think they want some movement or court interference. Since at present there is no forum and people can't gather to plan some legal remedy that's why they are doing all this in a slow motion. For Govt. employees even the court are not doing anything by taking into cognizance the issue. I THINK THE AUTHORITIES OF CGEWHO HAVE SOME MALAFIDE LINKS WITH BUILDERS.
They are waiting for FAR from GNIDA, in the mean time they can at least amend their bylaws to give an entry to New Pension Scheme Scheme, though legally it is not required as in their first advertisement they had never mentioned that Post 2004 Recruits can't apply hence SO MANY POST 2004 employees submitted the forms. I think there is no ADMINISTRATION in CGEWHO.
Not to talk about greedy builders - you can see how insensitive is Govt's own arm -CGEWHO. At least, after one year they should pay the interest or when new entrants come in, they should be charged the equilization charges as is done by NBCC, etc. Did u see how quick they were in deciding that no interest will be paid? And the same Govt. is bringing in Real Estate Accountability Act - truly ridiculous. It is learnt that CGEWHO purchased this land in GNOIDA in 1996 -perhaps, when nobody knew where this GNOIDA was. It must be at throw-away prices. Now, let us wait and see what cost they announce for the flats. God help applicants.
I applied for a home after my retirement because I had no place to shift after vacating the government accommodation. I have no son who could help me in providing shelter. Now in the wait of a home, I am paying heavy money for renting an accommodation for me and my wife. We are not living a comfortable life in rented accommodation and you are not taking any step to provide a house? Where to go such persons like me? Please Please do something for the sake for needy people.
You people are cheating to the applicants and deliberately doing the linger on this project and earning the interest from applicant's money. You are watching only self-interest not for applicants.
Is this not another kind of corruption wherein public money is being usurped by a group called ADMINISTRATORS ??
Did anyone calculate the amount collected by them on the tentative DU's..its huge..and they want us to wait until the scheme is declared while they keep the money without giving any interest or paying interest...
anonymous said:-
CGEWHO must have invested the crores of public money collected in r/o GNIDA in FDs etc. and have earned huge interest on that public money. But the height of cruelty and injustice to the innocent applicants is that CGEWHO is not giving any interest to them even after holding public money for more than 15 long months.
Last we herd about the meeting of 10th April. Now three months are over, we donot know what is happening. What type of WHO is this? please do some thing and update the applicants.
Three months are over..rather i don't understand how these people work....a decision can't be taken in 3 months of time after the last meeting..seems there are delaying it deliberately..who puts a tab on these people??..pathetic state of affairs in all govt offices..
Every time we called the office of CGEWHO they said within two months it will be announced but when they complete the so called two months . This is the height of corruption
When will you declare the allotte names? You don't have wright to keep the money with you. These are lifelong savings. Please do something to take decision soon.
Please, please expedite the process. It is overdue now. Pepole's hard-earned savings are lying idle, as no interest will be paid for the application money deposited.
when enterprises under govt of india like cgewho are so unresponsible towards govt employees as is clear from status of greater noida housing scheme and officials attitude ....god is watching you all ...bloody builders of a corrupt system!!!
all the moves till now reflect irresponsible behavior , lack of motivation and corrupt intensions of the CGEWHO.
This is nothing but a sheer harrassment to someone who has been nursing a dream of having a house in Delhi and NCR. As a poor government servant, I too paid the booking amount (1.80 lakh) by taking loan from the Bank. I have already paid about Rs.20,000/- as interest to the Bank. Seeing the snail's pace at which things are moving, I was sure to lose more money on account of interest. So I decided to withdraw from the GPF and pay the booking amount back to the Bank to avoid interest. Even after this, whether or not I will get one housing unit is not certain. What kind of stupid people are working for CGEWHO. They are ruthless, tyrranical and playing with the sentiments of poor government servants. Who was the fool who decided to exclude those who joined after 1.1.2004? Are they not government servants? What a shame to have such people at the helm?????
Simple Calculations to show how much money they holding at their end..
Tentative DU's for 1 bhk 60 - 60*60500 = 363000
Tentative DU's for 2 bhk 300 - 300*120500 = 36150000
Tentative DU's for 3 bhk 480 - 480*181000 = 86880000
Tentative DU's for 4 bhk 400 - 400*240000 = 96000000
Total it down and see the amount and calculate a bare minimum interest the bank will be willing to give on it..
please keep on telling about status of scheame,if it is going to be late for more 6 months then atleast provide the tentative price of each units so that we can think about some other market proposals which are very less now a days to book
Days are not far when someone will knock the door of the courts against these bloody fools sitting at the helm of affairs - called CGEWHO Boss. People are ready with RTI applications. Every pie will be accounted for. If they cannot manage the affiars, why these bunch of fools don't resign and hand it over to some energetic & efficient people to take over ? Friends, don't worry, for every single naya paise they will have to pay interest. Beware, its Anna Era !!!
Dr. Rakesh Singh
Oh GOD, Is there any one to give this case study to media citing a big example of inefficiency in govt Office. Now onwards W- Welfare words should removed from CGEWHO. and W should be replaced with H i.e Harassment. i is really ridiculous that CGEWHO does not know the definition of Central Govt Employee. NPS stared in 2004 and they are yet to know that they are illegible or not?
Friends, we should move a case to remove that CGEWHO CEO soon or mentioned this in his APAR/ACR.H might be a defunct/ Court Marshalled Colonel thrown out from Army.
July 18, 2012
One Under Secretary rank official of the CGEWHO said soemthing startling !! Big boss of the CGEWHO is intentionally dilli-dallying the process with some ulterior motive - everybody is in the know of it. The whistle blower is waiting for an opportune moment to bring the CAT OUT OF THE BAG VERY SOON. Friends, we have nothing to do or worry any more. Let the inner fight/tussle continue. JAI HIND, JAI CROOK CHEWHO.
Shame on cgewho
piease,it is requested to cgewho members do needful action for draw or intrest rate of payable earnest money by the sufferer.
Dear friends, it is reliably learnt that the big boss of the CGEWHO has managed to win the group who was desperately trying to bring the main culprit - the big fish, to book. Now if this is the situation friends, there is no hope for us to do anything now except to approach the appropriate authority for urgent relief. Underhand dealings are going on with the NOIDA Authority to keep the project hang up. It is better now to withdraw from the Scheme as future is very uncertain. Nobody is asking why the readvertisement has not come up as yet ? WE THE HAPLESS ARE NOT UNITED AND THATS WHY WE ARE SUFFERING AND THE IDIOTS ARE ENJOING THE FRUITS ! Friends, please unite and do something. Time is running out..........
it seems CGEWHO is acting in connivance with the builders of the area
There is considerable delay in declaring the draw for the Greater Noida Scheme. The official of CGEWHO should view the sentiments of poor Govt. employees and their aggression and further delay in the scheme should be avoided. People have limit of their tolerance. Delay in day by day may raise more and more doubts in people mind. So we earnestly request to publish the draw of the scheme as early as possible. Home these comments from the people are taken in right perception. Thanks.
If CGEWHO, which is an autonomous institution under the Ministry of Urban Development of the Union Government, cannot take up the case with appropriate
authorities to sort out the issues, it reflects very poorly on the argumentative
skills and administrative abilities on the part of the officials. CGEWHO is created solely for the purpose of providing affordable housing to central government employees. CGEWHO please finalise the project as expeditiously as possible as lot of hard-earned money of the employees are locked up without any result.
I THINK THEY R WAITING FOR RTI, NOT GIVING RIGHT ANSWER OR DOING QUICK DRAW.
I AM VERY HAPPY, BECAUSE ONE BY ONE WITHDRAW M0NY. AND IN THE LAST I WILL GET FLAT ON FIRST PRIORITY WITHOUT ANY DRAW.
THANKX CGEWHO FOR GOOD PLANNING.
Actions taken so far by CGEWHO should be made publiv and who is responsible for such a delay, should be brought to open.
I understand that there is conspiracy to flourish Private builders and where we poor govt employes should go.
Now we must approch Confedration of central Govt Employees to take up the matter at apropriate level about very poor working of CGEWHO.
All should come together and file a complaint or petition in Court.
I am also an applicant in this Scheme. My earnest request to authorities concerned is to take immediate steps for finalizing the requisite formalities and also voluntarily announce payment of interest that has become due after six months from launch of scheme. I also request the fellow applicants that kindly file RTI relevant to this Noida Housing scheme asking for amount of subscription they have received and also uptill now how much interest they have earned for information of all concerned so that CGEWHO feel the pressure and take necessary steps to declare the results.
please suggest what step to take at the earliest. As I am in the urgent need for the money and cgewho is paying no heed to the emotions of the investors.
pl for god shake pl help old persons waiting for the lottery, it is possible they may not witness due over delay, so do the needful at earliest.
with hope yours
Lack of clarity about the direction of the project, failure of communication between different stakeholders and parties
causing undue delay in the final decision .
Finally there is some good news for those who had applied in the Greater Noida Project. I had called up the office at Jan path and found out that GNIDA Authority has given the FAR to CGEWHO for 2100 units now.In this coming week wef 06August2012, CGEWHO is going to release the advertisement for NPS applicants and that we can be assured that the draw of lots will be conducted in September2012. However CGEWHO did not say anything about the pricing of the various types of units. I hope CGEWHO will keep their word and hold the draw in Sept2012 and I sincerely hope that they will also declare the costing of flats.After all it has indeed been a long time since we gave our initial deposits and nothing concrete turned up.I hope they will behave and act henceforth like an honest Govt organisation.
I have retired .pl provide house earliest
Atleast some clarification should come out from the CGEGHO as to why the project is getting unnecessarily delayed. Why the prospectgive beneficiaries are not being apprised of the status of the project through CGEWGHO website ? Whats the harm in it ? I am going to be retired within next two months. I am very eager to know the fate of my application - else I have to settle down in my home town - far away (1200 kms) from Delhi. I have two marriageable daughters. Please, please relieve me of this uncertainty at the sunset of my life !
THANKS
I SHOULD GET EXACT IDEA THAT IS FIRM DATE OF OCCUPPACY OF HOUSE.
REGARDS
The need of the hour is to form a association of all the applicants and should file public interest petition against the CGEWHO in High court for taking final decision on the matter which should end the uncertainity. Applicants from delhi should take lead in the initiative.
Exactly, CHEWHO is just testing how far the hapless govt babus can go, as they know it for certain that we cannot mobilise ourselves and only can bark. This is our loophole. Shame on us ! Also shame on me, as I cannot take the initiative to mobilise the affected persons and lead the agitation ! Lets see how far they can stretch out the matter and test our patience.
There is an urgent need to take the officials of the CGEWHO to task.Such poor accountability is unacceptable . By locking our hard earned money for so long we have been deprived of even exploring other options outside as prices continue to increase. Above all is the total lack of communication with the applicants. Looks like something fishy is going on. Let us fix a date and time when all of us will meet and go together to the CGEWHO
Lets form an association nothing moves in India without numbers
CGEWHO SHOULD DECLARE THE RESULT AND REFUND THE MONEY OF NON-ALLOTTEES, OTHERWISE PAY THE INTEREST.
when maximum FAR limit increased up to 3.5 by GNIDA.WHY CGEWHO going for 2.75.They must go for max possible FAR to accomadiate more applicant as weell as to bring down the prices.
I have invested my retirement money on this. I don't have home and now onwards I will be on road. Please do something to announce the allotte names or returned back the money to us. These are hard earning money of Govt. employees.
I WANT TO KNOW HOW MUCH INTEREST EARNED BY CGEWHO TILL DATE. EVERYBODY IS WAITING FOR THE DRAW TO BE HELD AND INTEREST @ 18 PER CENT BE PAID TO THE APPLICANTS AS PVT BUILDERS DEMAND IN CASE OF LATE PAYMENT. AS PER ADVT. DRAW WAS TO BE HELD IN THREE MONTHS BUT NOW IT IS MORE THAN 15 MONTHS. WHO EATS OUR INTEREST ? WE MUST APPLY RTI REPLIES FROM THEM WHY DELAY AND WHY NO INTEREST. AFTER THAT, WE MUST APPROACH THE MEDIA AND COURT TO DECIDE WHY THIS DELAY AND DELAY AND FIX THE RESPONSIBILITIES OF THE OFFICERS CONCERNED AND PUNSHING THEM IF THEY ARE WRONG. OR ATLEAST THEY SHOULD PAY INTEREST IF THERE IS DELAY IN DRAW . WE WANT NATURAL JUSTICE AND NOT BEGGING. WE WILL WIN CERTAINLY IF WE FIGHT - GOOD LUCK TO ALL OF U.
PLS PAY INTEREST @ 18 PERCENT AS PVT BUILDERS DEMAND IN CASE OF LATE PAYMENT. PEOPLE SHOULD WRITE FOR RTI REPLIES AND GIVE THE REPLIES TO MEDIA PERSONS AND WE CAN ALSO GO TO THE COURT AND ASK WHERE OUR MONEY HAS GONE DURING THE LAST 15 MONTHS AND HOW MUCH THEY HAVE EARNED FROM OUR DEPOSITS.OUR SINCERE EFFORTS WILL CERTAINLY BEAR SOME FRUIT. GOOD LUCK.
Dear friends,
Good idea. some one has to take the lead. Lets gather in front of Cgewgho office/indian oil bhawan. Have anybody guts to come at the cost of only a day's C.L.? If there is unanimity, let fix the date for 31 Aug 2012 (friday) at 11 A.M. sharp. Even if 50 people gather, we will be able to gather some vital information the the cgewgho boss (its shame to call them boss !). Then, friends, it is fixed on 31.8.2012 Friday at 11 AM. Please do come for sake of ourvelves only. Lets see how many feedback is received at this site. I am not mentioning my name lest I become the fallguy of the cgewgho management. It is obvious. We all should remain anonymous till our proposed gathering on 31st. Good luck and jai hind !
Something is going to take place within next one month. We must havbe patience since we have walked a long path. But we should not forget the INTEREST ACCRUED ON OUR DEPOSITED AMOUNT. They should disclose how much interest our appliction money has earned. Please be united on this single point.
Read about the upcoming project at greater Noida. I am unable to make out whether the retired central government employee who does not have his own house is eligible to apply or not? Please Clarify.
Thanks
Rajendra Prasad
its my humble request to all applicants kindly be active and lets gather in front of cgewho office & keep on sending RTI application and queries through e mails . don't let this scheme go into hands of corrupt people who r planning to take advantage.
please, please................do something over this issue.
Now at long last, some relief is in sight. The Kumbhkarn has awaken from deep slumber. Dear friends, keep the pressure going. Be vocal on this site, otherwise they will again dilly-dally the project. Even now, everything is not crystal clear. See, 10th september is the last date of application. Hardly a week's time is required to scrutinize the new applications. That is, by the end of September we may legitimtely expect the date of DRAW !! Dear applicants, in my next post i will give you an idea about the proposed approx cost of a flat. Yes, i am privy to this news. I know the cost of the land procured from Mulayam govt. long long ago.
I am from income tax department, under new pension scheme. I wanna know that whether i can apply for this scheme or not.
Applicants of type A & B will be most benefited, as there is less competition. Those who have applied or will be applying for type B will be 90% sure of allotment in the draw. So is the case of type A. Maximum number of people have applied for type C and therefore there will be huge competition and chance of allotment in the draw is roughly 13.5%, where as in type B chance is 79%, and in type A it is 74%. In category/type
D is chance of allotment is 39%.
Brother from Income Tax deptt., surely you are eligible. Better apply for type D if you have strong purse, otherwise go for type A. Competition is less in these two categories. Choice is yours.
BREAKING NEWS....., BREAKING NEWS,......BREAKING NEWS,
If people are not cheated again, following will be the approx cost of each flat :
Type A - Rs. 8,22,000 - 10,27,500 (after price escalation)
Type B - Rs.13,87,500 - 16,65,000 (after price escalation)
Type C - Rs.18,00,000 - 21,76,500 (after price escalation)
Dype D - Rs.25,80,000 - 30,96,000 (after price escalation)
Be united. They may tinker with these figures to our disadvantage.
thanx for the information... from income tax deptt.
i wanna know that whether i can apply for more than 2 flats or not
I have applied for C type ,can I switch over for D type by before draw .
You may send an urgent request to cgewho. They may consider - they may not. It is upto them. In my case too, I have sent a request. But nothing has been heard so far. We are at their mercy.
Sorry you can not change category ... that is a surprisingly dumb query
one year already past please tell me when the action taken of draw of g.d.scheme
Employees in this 7 year band (2004 to 2011) will apply now. The total number will increase.. any guesses how much the number will become?
I think the total applicants may go upto 5000 to 5,500/- and each category will be swelling by 15-25% .
My guess is on higher side but that is perhaps realistic...
What say ? Any more guesses?
it has been learnt that cgewho authorities are hands in gloves with private builders in the area and thereby making every effort to jeopardise the projec
Friends, there will be huge goof-ups; be ready to get the rejection letter and also wait for the appliction money. There will be a pre-planned and pre-orchestrated draw of lots. Its very easy to manipulate the computerized draw. Just wait and see !
OK huge goof-ups...possible... this greater noida lottery looks quite a dramatic wonder blunder...hope ultimately I get what I want ...God favour me all the luck :-P
Plot area of greater noida scheme is 40 acre. FAR limit is increasedfrom 275 to 350 by greater noida authorty.Why CGEWHO AUTHORTIES not trying for higher FAR. With maximum FAR approx 5000 flats can be built.By doing so dream of many more famailies can be full filled at reduceed price.
Dear, please understand more the numbers, more the strength of the allottees. Because less people will not be able to unite and have a forceful say against the CGEWHO management. Otherwise, they should have utilized max FAR - what they are going to loose ? Nobody has even bothered to find out from the noida authority what was the cost of the allotted land. Its a throwaway price. Because at that time people even did not dream of going to settle/live in Greater Noida. Now a days, its a developmed area. Please be careful, we will pay the exact cost price of the land plus building costs etc. BUT NEVER TODAY'S ESCALATED PRICE OF THE ALLOTTED LAND ACQUIRED LONG LONG AGO.
Hum intezaar karenge tera qayamat tak .... :-)
I think this is a five year plan.
why this scheme is taking so much time ?
that is the reason nobody have faith in govt.
CGEWHO mentioned that they shall endevour for increase in FAR & maximise number of houses .Now maximum permissible limit of FAR in greater Noida is 350.Hence CGEWHO must try for what they promised .By utilizing maximum FAR they can give flats to 90 to 100% applicants.
Agree..
rumour... NPS holder must apply for Type-B
Kab tak sab kuchh settle hoga?
Please CGEWHO enhance the last date of submission of application.
I and my colleagues have applied for type 'B', As per my consensus, there might be huge application for the Type 'B' as it is cost effective so there will be much competition for Type 'B'. Most of the person are only applying for the investment purposes, not for any requirements.
Property rates in that area is 2600 Rs/sqft.
so present rate will as follows..
1BHK 2600 x 685 = 17,81000
2BHK 2600 x 1110 = 28,86000
3BHK 2600 x 1445 = 36,79000
4BHK 2600 x 2064 = 53,66400
We are bloody fools - Lala Dukhi Chand breed ! From this site, it seems everybody is waiting that someone else would speak on his/her behalf. If this is not so, this site should have been more vocal. Thats why we are befooled so easily and we can only lament afterwards ! Come on, be vocal, share some thought so that we all are united for a common cause - a roof on our head, at least !
Please all applicants- write down your name & phone numbers below.. I will call everyone for gathering and further course of action against CGEWHO.
the land has been purchased in 1996 @ Rs600 per sq meter. therefore per sq cost of land is about Rs 55. Hence the cost should be, keeping in view CGEWHo a non profit organisatio, 55 plus 1300rs sq construction cost. Take 500 lac per head in to account for the common area
land alloted @ 600 per sq meter. approx 55rs per sq ft
I was informed by the Reception of CGEWHO, Janpath that the price will not be less than 2700 Rs/square feet. What the hell going on???
Dear friends,
latest news - draw of lots is expected in the 3rd week of Feb 2013 ! At least, CGEWHO have come out with a probable date ! It is high time we withdraw from the scheme and invest in some upcoming projects in noida expressway.
Wh.................a......t ? Sooooooooooo.....late ?
RTI is the only redressal. Just wait..............
ARe bhaiya 28 sitambar ko draw of lots hai...28 sitamber ko....samajh lo ab bela aa gayi kismat ki jaanch ki...
D type mein to underbidding hui hai...so no problem there all who applied there will surely get it...
But what is the rate?????
total applicants:
For TYPE TOTAL APPLICATIONS TOTAL DUs
A 410 104
B 1948 506
C 1774 830
D 610 690
Thanks for the data buddy...
scene is great for type D
At Unitech heights the rates are areoung Rs 3000/- to 3500/- per sqft as per magicbricks...
How much should the rte be for us?
I guess it should be around Rs 2000/- (or less) per sqft considering that land was acquired long back at very low rates...
Numbers
Type D : Applicants 625: Flats 690
Type C : Applicants 1804: Flats 830
Type B : Applicants 1980: Flats 506
Type A : Applicants 404 : Flats 104
Tera kya hoga Kaliya?
Thanks for the data of no. of applicants vis-a-vis no. of DUs as also about the prevalent rates in GN area. Of late, I have heard about cost and time over-runs in CGEWHO schemes. Yaar, kya ye bhi builder hi hote ja rahe hain??? Lucky ones in the draw should fight for early completion of the project. Already too much delay for such a small thing - which could have been solved much earlier pending post facto approval by the Governing Council.
the cgewho keeps insisting the rates will be 2700...plus a minimum cost escalation of 50 % ( the project is sure to be delayed going by the history of cgewho)...five years from now we would hav paid 3500+...private builders are booking flats in noida extension at rates below this...even the jaypee greens in noida was around 4000 some time back...and these buildrs dont escalate...i wonder if it will be a sensible decision to invest in a non transparent non professional cgewho?
cgewho has already befooled the applicants...when the scheme was announced the property rates in greater noida were 2000 ( or even lss in dec 2010) we invested then keeping hope on a so called no profit no lloss policy..now if they sell at more than that and escalate further we have been robbed of our investment opportunity which we had 2 years back...plus those looking for investmet try to understand that greater noida does not have resale market for flats now ( or even 5 years from now) since occupancy rates are still low . end users will have no choice however...the only solution is RTI USE KARO TRY TO FIND OUT HOW DO THEY CALCULATE THE COST . THE ONLY WAY THEY CAN ASK FOR A >2000 RATE IS IF THEY ESCALATE THE LAND PRICES...AND THEY WILL DO THAT...HOW SENSIBLE IS IT FOR A NO PROFIT NO LOSS BODY TO ESCALTE LAND PRICES AT THE SAME RATE AS THE MARKET PLAYERS...PLUS HOW DO THEY ACCOUNT FOR THE 25 ODD CRORE OF INTERST MONEY THEY HV ACCUMULATED. IRWO HAVE ANNOUNCED THE RATES OF THEIR FLATS AT 2700 IN NOIDA EXTENSION EVEN WHEN THEY HAVE NOT PURCHASED LAND FROM GNIDA ..CGEWHO OWNS THE LAND SINCE 1996..MOREOVER THEY ARE BUILDIND 2100 FLATS AS AGAINST 400 OF IRWO...MOREOVER PROPERTY RATES OF NOIDA EXTENSION ARE MORE THAN GN...APPLICANTS RISE UP U HV BEEN CHEATED ONCE ,,,DONT GET CHEATED AGAIN
check the fate of various cgewho schemes...
http://www.facebook.com/media/set/?set=a.382432128441442.95719.363770266974295&type=3
http://kendriya-vihar-kolkata-flatbazar.blogspot.in/
http://www.facebook.com/pages/Central-Gov-Employee-Welfare-housing-OrganizationCGEWHO/375158015834314?ref=ts
http://www.orkut.co.in/Main#CommMsgs?cmm=112855634&tid=5592321670406436053
http://chennaikv2.blogspot.in/2008/11/latest-photograph-of-chennai-phase-ii.html
and there is more ...in fact all the schemes of cgewho have looted the poor government servants.BE CAUTIOUS WHILE INVESTING.
Unless there is significant monetary advantage it will remain seriously debatable to go for this scheme... what say???
I am expecting a good economic leverage from cgewho... afterall that is what CGEWHO's prime objective...
At this point of time greater noida is far away from where the action si... so I would expect the rates to be low... It is already 55 km away from delhi airport and about 45 km from New delhi railwaya station ( agreed one doesn't go to railwaya station and airport everyday but still..)
Moreover I would expect a difference of Rs 1000/- per square ft from that of private builders.
There is one good thing though that the rates are still far far far better than what they have in Mumbai... they have such a rotten rate going on due to builder politician nexus..
let us sincerely hope ki rates private builders se kam ho aur time and cost overruns are avoided...but the real risk is the true cost of the flat is visible in the last instalment...as was in the case of jaipur where they shocked the beneficiaries by increasing cost 25-30 % in the last instalment....hey bhagwan why doesnt CAG catch hold of these people.
Good links mate...
This area is close to Unitech heights...and one airforce welfare assoc... anyone has any idea about the construction there?
good inputs... I have never seen any cgewho housing complex...atleast never from inside..
anyone knows what is the quality and public space provided in any CGEWHO housing complexes in delhi ?
when is the building plan and layout expected?
and ofcourse rate/price !
The total area of land is roughly around 0.5 kilometer x 0.5 kilometer (measured by google earth ruler) 500 meter x 500 meter = 1650 ft x 1650 ft roughly... = 27,22,500 sqft.
With highrises in mind there can be very good open space around the buildings I believe.
If planned well it can be nice place to stay..- Formula 1 race track is around 10 Kilometers from here...
Let us hope for a smooth run to the completion of housing complex
draw of lots is only 3 days away...
overall layout and Building floor plan is eagerly awaited
same here
she replied same to me
Hello I have opted for type-C without much considerations. Now if i get the lucky draw, i would like to mutually change it to type-A or B. If anybody would like to change mutually ..plz intimate me.. Kishore
hurrrrayyy... I have been allotted C type flat in todays draw......
letc c how much cost dey wll charge.....any idea.....
Congrtulations
I also applied for C-type but luckey.
Me too, lucky winner (unlucky, if the price is manipulated). Inside news 1150/ sq ft is the rate ! More than that, friends, be ready to move the court after filing and taking all information through RTI.
CGEWHO must initiate necessary action regarding payment of interest on the deposited amount to all the unsuccessful applicants .
D type flats are under subscribed. how remaining flat will be alloted.
if any one interested in exchange with D type flats , pl reply
too low for the area...proprty there will always be around 2500...1150 is not digestable..
Dear friends, Rs, 1150/- sq. ft. why not disgestable. Agreed, price in that area may be 2500/-, but understand one thing, builders make profit is approx 30-40%. They have to grease the palm of so many stake holders. But in this case, CGEWHO is the govt orgn. and they are not going to give any undercut to anybody. It is only the building cost/material cost etc (i.e. the overall constructuion cost)plus some other misc cost. Here there is no PROFIT. For example if a builder flat costs Rs. 35 lakhs, the builder makes a profit 10,50000/-at least(even if it is 30%). In that case actual cost price comes to 24,50,000/-. Is it clear, my dear pessimit friends ? Pl. logically ponder over it and don't go by hearsay only. Good luck & good investing!
2000 to 2500 can be justified, but over phone they told 2700, now on 28th they told 3000. i do not know, how will they justify it, when cost of land (acquisition) was 130 per Sq-ft in 2010. any way we will request for cost justification.
Govt made projects are normally costly, but they can not depend on area rates, as land was bought long back (1996, stone ages for property rates)
we should create a facebook page to keep all allottess united
this project is not going to work out...everyone will withdraw at 3000 yaar...who will invest when reputed builders are selling at 3000 in noida extension...
I am planning to get a Stay-Order from the court if CGEWHO reduces the rate from Rs. 2700 sqr/feet as informed by them. Why did they misguide people? I might get a D-type flat but i could not apply for Type-D because of the their prices (i.e 2700 sqr/feet) and lost the chance. The draw should be conducted again after the price declaration.
who told that the land was acquired on 2006???
the land acquired may be at stone ages but the additional FAR purchased was very costly( they claim it)....effectively we can calculate the total cost of project at Rs 3000 psf x ( total square feet to be created ) calculating it ..i get the result at around 1100 crores....the cgewho project is costing us 1100 crore of which the cost of land bought in 1996 is just 10 crores....hahaha CGEWHO STOP BEFOOLING US...
d type is undersubscribed mate...u can apply when the scheme is reopened for priority 2 or 3....why r u creating more roadbocks in a already traffic jam situation..and dont worry the price will not be far from 2700
Untill declared on website the rate can not be known to anyone... Rs 2700/- or Rs 1700/- per sqft ...
Nothing is clearly known untill they declare it on their website..
So wait for it to be finally sure...
Since this scheme has been the talk of the town I do not think there can be any 'chakkar' now... I am sure the rate will be favourable for most of us...
Dear friends let us wait and watch...
All are humbly requested:-
Please don't abuse to anyone.
Be informative and just deny any wrong information with use of reply link to every comments.
Bad words is not necessity for exchange of information.
agree and sharing of information is imp.
traffic jam for this scheme is really bad, but i do not understand one thing, most of their schemes are under subscribed, this scheme looks highly in demand.
their prices in other schemes are O.K, but for this scheme they are quoting very high prices over phone. Rates in central govt organisations for constructing residential houses don't go more than 2000(with out taking land cost) for very good specifications, how will they account for 2700-2800.
Agreed, this platform is for the mutual benefit of all members of cgewho. we should not indulge in badmouthing. On the contrary, every member also has a responsibility not to spread rumour or come out with such insensible comments which will, ultimately, turned boomerangue against each of us. So friends, be calm. Let the chewho declare their prce tag - it is only after that we may move unitedly. t
I have been allotted a Type C. However, I am moving out of India in a months time for 2 years. Can anyone tell what shall be the procedure next after allotment of DU and how long will it take? Can I work by giving power of attorney?
My friend who is going out of the country, not to worry at all. Contact a property dealer who will act on your behalf behind the shadow. Take out a hefty premium from him and give him the power of attorney (indirect sale !). So simple !
All beneficiaries should register themselves on face book and interact with fellow members for building pressure on CGewho for transparent dealings. Beneficiaries should also form an Association for meeting /delegation etc. A. Tripathi Mobile -9868332285 Email:anitripathi@hotmail.com
yes
All beneficiaries should register themselves on face book and interact with fellow members for building pressure on CGewho for transparent dealings. Beneficiaries should also form an Association for meeting /delegation etc. A. Tripathi Mobile -9868332285 Email:anitripathi@hotmail.com
please provide the facebook link so that i can register myself for the same ..H K Manak (8826050539)
Someone posted this on Aug 20th.
AnonymousAugust 20, 2012 6:10 PM
BREAKING NEWS....., BREAKING NEWS,......BREAKING NEWS,
If people are not cheated again, following will be the approx cost of each flat :
Type A - Rs. 8,22,000 - 10,27,500 (after price escalation)
Type B - Rs.13,87,500 - 16,65,000 (after price escalation)
Type C - Rs.18,00,000 - 21,76,500 (after price escalation)
Dype D - Rs.25,80,000 - 30,96,000 (after price escalation)
Be united. They may tinker with these figures to our disadvantage.
Rs 1500 per sqft should be the rate. Otherwise there is no point in booking here.
Type A - Rs. 8,22,000 - 10,27,500 (after price escalation)
Type B - Rs.13,87,500 - 16,65,000 (after price escalation)
Type C - Rs.18,00,000 - 21,76,500 (after price escalation)
Dype D - Rs.25,80,000 - 30,96,000 (after price escalation)
funny... even you can't purchase bricks of flats by theses figures buddy
wake up from day dreeming bro..
why funny ? It seems either you are not a successful registrant or you have ill-gotten money. Any middle income person will think loically on the the estimated price given above.
Jaipur allotees were given flats at the rates of 2000 per sq feet after escalation. Anyone has idea at what cost land was alloted to CGEWHO there?
Open your eyes and ears buddy. you can get flats cheaper than these rates.
if it is going more than 2200 per Sq-ft, then we are doomed, and which brick material, above person is talking about.
land was cheap, acquired at 130 per Sq-ft in 2010, According to their site (from minutes of meetings at their web page)loan of 58 crore was taken for increasing FAR. that comes nearly 260 per Sq-ft. Add 1500 per Sq-ft for cinstruction and nearly 400 per Sq-ft, price should not be more than 2200 per Sq-ft. Please add any other expense below,which i am missing.
above given price is not possible, but arranging more money than that is also not possible. one more thing, if price is more than that, will we get HBA.
faltu.com makes sense as it is based on some recent research from Jaipur case...
2000 Rs to 2200/- could be realistic...
Whne pvt builders can provide flats in 2500/- per sqft then Rs 2200 per sqft may look ridiculous...
At the most it should be 1800/- per sqft
Greater Noida land must have been cheaper than Jaipur land I believe... what say?
Of course, G.Noida land was much cheaper than that of Jaipur. Jaipur area is more developed and people are cultured in around Jaipur than G.Noida, where mostly .......type of people live there presently. I have every detailed knowledge of the rates at which CGEWHO acquired that piece of land and other misc. expenditure incurred on converting bigger FAR. At the appropriate/opportune time it will be disclosed in this platform and in the Courts of Law. A few CGEWHO people in the management of the organization cannot hold the successful registrants to ransom. Friends, don't worry.... rate won't be more than Rs. 1700/- (plus minus Rs. 200/- per sqf). Just have patience. Let the demand letter come, the cat will come out of the bag !!!!!
I was just hitting on another projects of CGEWHO e.g JAIPUR (PHASE II)OPEN FOR GENERAL PUBLIC ON 'FIRST COME.FIRST SERVED' BASIS @ http://cgewho.nic.in/JJ_A_GP.pdf
The price of B type flat (1092 rs/sqft) is 27 lacs, I cant understand why the hell these flats are so costly?? Same rates have also been implemented for Type B flats in the scheme of so called LUCKNOW??
Why should it be cheapee..? i am from jaipur
Sir, I dont know much about this project/rates/cgewho. All i just know that i am a poor govt. servant with limited or fixed salary (GP-4200) only earning man from my family. After reading this forum, I think that i will not be able to pay the installments of such huge amounts for type C. I dont want to entangle in sleepless nights. please provide pros & cons of House Building Advances?? can we take HBA and bank loan both?? Advice plz
loan and hba at the same time will ruin you..if u r eligible for HBA ( 10 yrs service ) take it ( maxm limit 30 lakhs ...chk swamy's handbook for the emi details. for a person with a 30000 pm salary your hba advance will be limited ( 134 times i think) plus if u want to take loan then cheapest is sbi (10.2 ) but at 30000salary banks will not give more than 20 lakhs for 20 year loan....private banks can give u more but they charge higher interst....only solution is mate ki cost ko negotiate kiya jaye
max HBA amount is 7.5 Lakhs only, so any way bank loan will be required. and negotiate kiya kis se jayega, if these people keeps on delaying, it will increase the cost only.
one more thing, what are the rates in that area.
jaipur and lucknow are ready to move flats, hence interest comes into picture, chennai they gave 1600 per Sq-ft(final), now lady on phone tells different rates every time, try it some time.
Rates are 2400 per sq ft for fully constructed flat. under construction are available at 2000 upwards. you cannot get HBA if cost of the house is more than 30 lakhs.
cgewho got land practically free in greater noida. 600 per sq meter. their cost of construction is 1000- 1200 square feet.
Yea I guess with all these opinions the rate should not go above Rs 2000 per sqft even in the worst case...
My gut feeling is that it will be around Rs 1700/ per sqft.
Greate noida is much far away and it will be difficult for cgewho to invite people with a rate more than Rs 2000 per sqft...
greater noida scheme was started in 2011, scheme was delayed due to their definition of Govt employee, but who stopped them from calculating cost of project and master plan.
CGEWHO should not say that they were waiting for increase in FAR.
Any way who stopped them from making master plans for two FARs of 150 and 275. now delay for waiting for FAR will increase the project cost, which we will have to pay.
if CGEWHO says that two master plans can't be made for one scheme( even if that reduce the overall costs), then it should not say that it is autonomous body for benefit of people under a ministry, which has poverty alleviation in its name.
one more point, max limit for HBA is 30 laks plus 25 % increase in special case, hence how CGEWHO can show their construction cost to be very high, when overall land cost is vry low.
CGEWHO may perhaps decide about the rate within a month's time..
Greater Noida???
So far away... it is a far flung satellite town of a satellite itself Noida...
Do u think people are going to stay there ever??? even Rs 1500 per sqft is much too much to invest...
After all Greater Noida is in UP...
Northern India can never be as safe as Mumbai or Southern part of India...hence the rates are likewise...
1500 Rs per sqft is ideal... someone gave that rate chart earlier
In no case should it go more than Rs 2000 persqft.
We are still guessing the rate… whereas CGEWHO has sent letter to unsuccessful applicant.
Reception is telling Rs. 3000 as price for the scheme.
Why there is delay in fixing rate? Are they are still checking the public mood for the rate
reception started from 2700 and reached 3000, it looks like airlines tickets, more clicks on their sites and rates increase, same way great cgewho is working, more calls for inquiry, and their rates go up.
in chennai rates were 1600 per Sq-ft. and safety issues are there in southern india also.
Ha ha ha ! one of my friends has done a sting opeation of Cgewho's big boss. Shortly it will be in the out friends ! How they fleece and manipulate govt employees will be coming out with a bang ! just wait !!! Something is still coooooooking up. RATE OF GNOIDA WILL NOT, IN ANY WAY, MORE THAN Rs. 1500/sqft.
3000 mein to koi naheen lega...
Can I sell, present or transfer my C-type flat (which is presently in papers) to my family member? how? or can i withdraw from the scheme now?
Yes,I want to have the right of your flat, which is presently on paper only. I want a 'C' type flat (3 BHK) only. Modus operandi is I will start paying out all costs/instalments on your behalf. You have to give me only a POA. And at the time of possession, I will take care of the flat in question. I will give you a PREMIUM of Rs. 3,00,000/- (3 las) cash. You may consider you have won a lottery of Rs. 3 lacs. My mobile :9958365603. Better I will call you. Interested parties may leave their mobile/contat numbers in this blog. THANKS
bro.. since I think there is no reasonable ground to pay such huge amount to cgewho for a flat in Greater Noida and one of my relative working in Noida is interested in my flat.
so sory for that..
Ke kar raya hai bhaaya ? Rate to aa jaane de pehle ???:-) mhanne to sahi lag raya hai je greater noida...
NO PREMIUM AT ALL. SOMEONE IS SPREADING RUMOUR ON THIS SITE. THE AREA IS NOT FULLY DEVELOPED. IT IS BETTER TO HAVE A FLAT AT SONEPAT, BHIWADI, MOHALI IF ONE CANMNOT AFFORD NOIDA OR GURGAON. THERE WILL BE NO APPRECIATION OF PROCE EVEN AT LEAST FOR 5/6 YEARS. ONLY, ONLY IF METRO (NEAR THE PROJECT) AND AIRPORT COMES UP AT G.NOIDA, THEN ONLY ONE CAN EXPECT SOME APPRECIATION OTHERWISE IT IS WISE AND BETTER TO COME OUT FROM THIS SCHEME. PRICE IS REALLY .. REALLY TOO HIGH ! IF THE PRICE REMAINS WITHIN 1500-1800/PSFT, IT IS OK. THATS ALL, FRIENDS !
But they say Greater Noida is going to be the best planned city of India ??? Night safari, Formula-1 race track and many other features that make the place comparable with the best around the world??? Possibly it is worth waiting for 5/6 years and then possibly the development will make everyone realize the investment was worth it...???
Bhai sahab suspense bada khatarnaak hua ja raha hai....
Will it end in a disaster of Rs 3000 per sqft or will it end up as a pleasant surprise of Rs 1000/- per sqft ???
Noida and Greater Noida are any day 50 times better than Navi Mumbai ( huh what a trash !).But the rates in Navi Mumbai are 5 times higer than Greater Noida...
why the hell cost is not getting disclosed? the rate of newly constructed flats are being offered at Rs 2300-2400 psf by many builders. Cgewho being non profit organisation can offer it much much cheaper say 1300-1400 psf?
what if any one withdraws after the leter is issued by cgewho?
one of my relative has purchased a 4 room flat by a reputed builder in GN for about 3000 per sqft. but it comes with various modern facilities and amnities. I am not sure whether cgewho provides these modern facilities like gym, swimming pool, club, auditorium etc etc
Greater Noida has lot of potential in it. Though it is not fully developed. People have gone there earlier to have their house on cheaper rates just 6-8 years back but now it is not cheaper as it has to be. And if CGEWHO also behaves like builder mafia for asking higher rates then it is not worth for common Govt. servant to have the flat. Resale vaule for flat is much lower than other places like Noida/Ghazibad and also rental value is also just half of Noiad. So I mean to say that rate must be half of the Noida rate as have been earlier. But present rates are not half. By staying there one can not rely on public TPT. You have to spent 2 hours to reach Delhi. As I am resident of Gr noida since 2003. So in nut shell rates of CGEWHO flat must be arount 2000/- sqft. SPS Yadav
Are you ready to shell out 61 lakh for a 4 bed in GN and that too of CGEWHO atthe rate of Rs 3000 persqft?
Ab to sab kuchh Diwali ke baad hi hoga rate wate sab
Yea they will give some time to applicants for withdrawing...rest assured...
bro.. tell me the builder name who is providing flat in 2300-2400 psf in GN..!!! All builders are asking 3200 to 3400 psf rate.
Sahi kaha Yadav ji...Mujhe bhi aisa hi lagta hai...I hope they provide good material in the flats and good planning
So far Greater Noida is quite a sleepy place...market rate may not pick p in 5/6 years... so .. investors can keep away...
People who want to buy flat for living may find it good
le lo bhai le lo. bad me dekha jaiga.
after 25th October there is no updation on this blog. It seems people mamaging this site are hands in glove with cgewho management. Successful registrants please be vigilant. I am not sure whether this article will appear in this blog. I myself have posted article twice in the last fortnight giving valuable inputs. But it is vanished !!!!
Please click here to see your comments http://karnmk.blogspot.in/2012/08/cgewho-greater-noida-housing-scheme.html
-----------------------------GREATER NOIDA SCHEME----------
Applicants of greater Noida , please get united and represent against CGEWHO, format of representation and agenda is attach in below link.
http://www.facebook.com/#!/pages/Central-Gov-Employee-Welfare-housing-OrganizationCGEWHO/375158015834314?fref=ts
please send in mass , so that our grivences are given importance, pressure is builtup on CGEWHO for providing affordable houses.
please contact for query
9716139694
-----------Greater Noida Scheme----------
Please go to Related post i.e Represntation to CGEWHO for greater Noida Housing Scheme
please read carefully and submit application to cgewho & all council members.
every individual should take responsibility and represent to have mass representation, to built pressure on CGEWHO.
we have already submitted representation.
suresh 9716139694
IT SEEMS PRICE IS 1700/PSF AND THE SAME IS CALCULATED ON THE BASIS OF PREVAILING MARKET RATE THEN EXISTED IN 2011.
what is latest news regrading noida flats,
whether cgewho closed or what???
i will try to find out,
Post a Comment